OAKLAND, Sept. 2, 2009 -- Ryan Sweeney was in the No. 3 spot for the A's today, and while he's got a lot to prove about his ability to drive the ball before he actually gets moved into a run-production spot full-time, the fact that he's in there shows he's making progress.
With that in mind, I started toying with various lineup permutations today, factoring in free agency, arbitration, potential non-tenders, etc., before coming up with what I think is a fairly realistic lineup for 2010.
"Realistic," with all due respect to Eric Chavez, eliminates him from consideration. Free agency takes Adam Kennedy out of the mix, and arbitration says see ya to Jack Cust and Scott Hairston. Everyone else in the organization is in play, and here's what I came up with.
I think the A's brass might like it. It's cheap as all get-out. But the fans should like it, too. At the very least, it holds promise.
1) Rajai Davis, CF. First prototypical leadoff man since ... who? Rickey? He wasn't really a prototype. He was a freak. Rajai doesn't have that kind of pop, but he's the most exciting baserunner the A's have had in years, and were it not for him, the 2009 team would be a stone-cold bore half the time.
2) Mark Ellis, 2B. Selfless, handles the bat well, bunts well, good plate discipline, decent pop. That's about all you need in a No. 2 hitter.
3) Ryan Sweeney, RF. This, admittedly, is a major stretch. Sweeney only recently has shown signs of the power many people within the game -- including Frank Thomas -- have long said Sweeney will develop with time. But let's not forget the dude's only 24. And if he works on a power stroke during the winter and pops a handful of balls out in the desert at Spring Training, it might be worth seeing how he responds to the role. There's nobody else on the roster with enough big league experience (the possible exception being Kurt Suzuki) even remotely suited for it.
4) Landon Powell, DH. Another stretch, but like with Sweeney, the stretch is in the lineup spot, not that he's in the lineup. Get another catcher. Powell's too good of a hitter to sit as much as he does, and his health is such that he'll never be a regular in the field. Cleanup's not ideal, but nobody said this was going to be an ideal lineup. And ideal lineup would have a healthy Eric Chavez in this spot and playing third, right?
5) Chris Carter LF. I'm still not convinced he'll be a big league outfielder, mostly because I've only seem him out there three times in person, but there are better defensive options at first base, and let's be honest: Carter can't possibly be worse on defense than Jeremy Giambi or Emil Brown or some of the other stiffs who have manned the position in recent years, and if you can stick with him through the inevitable struggled of April and May, you'll probably see his track record of June-September monstrosity come to life on the big stage.
6) Suzuki, C. Maybe the best No. 6 hitter this side of the Bronx, bringing pop and balance to the lower half of the order.
7) Sean Doolittle, 1B. Scouts are as high on this kid as they are on Carter, but Doolittle has been hurt a lot. He's a solid defender and a power bat on the come. If he doesn't pan out, there's always Daric Barton, who looks a million times more comfortable at the plate these days and has turned himself into a plus defender. He won't kill you in the No. 7 spot, that's for sure.
8) Brett Wallace, 3B. Chavez would be nice, but again, you have to be realistic. Wallace is never going to be the glove man that Chavez has been, but the boy can rake, and with Chavez serving as something of a mentor, you never know. Bottom line, the fans want to see the guy, and there's no better option at the posotion. Time to start the clock.
9) Cliff Pennington, SS. If the power at the corners pans out, you can put up with a defense-first shortstop, and that's how i see Pennington at this point. He makes all the plays. Nothing spectacular, but solid, with a solid partner up the middle in Ellis. And with Pennington's speed in front of Davis, an element the A's have been sorely lacking for years will be in play.
Feel free to mock, debate, argue and come up with something better. That's what this forum is for. I can poke a million holes in this lineup myself, but unless you go to free agency, I don't think the A's have many more attractive options.
And if you think a legit free agency doesn't see Oakland as a graveyard for veterans right now, come sit on poppa bear's lap. I'll explain it all to you.
By the way, bid a fond farewell to 20-year-old Adam Loberstein, who did a heckuva job covering the team as my associate reporter this summer. I'm sticking the bulk of today's game coverage on him today, because if A's-Royals in September doesn't say, "Nice work, Chachi," what does?
Peace, lightly salted cashews and Saliva's "Click Click Boom" to all ...
--Mychael Urban